Sunday, 10 April 2011

Haydn did it first (continued)

Slow fast slow fast

Here is the last movement of Beethoven's quartet opus 18 number 6, La Malinconia

Here Beethoven created a new form for a quartet movement: the interleaving of a slow, elegaic section with a fast and sprightly one. Beethoven returned to this bipolar form, in different variations, in later quartets (for example, the serioso movement of opus 95, the first movement of opus 127, the first movement of opus 130). It was later a favorite form of Brahms, who used it in his quartets, his sextets, and in the horn trio.

It was a new form. Or, almost a new form. Because Haydn tried it out first. His "Sunrise" quartet, opus 76 number 4. is essentially in this form:

In this movement, there are no tempo markings to separate the elegaic section from the allegro one; but the movement is built on the contrast between the two alternating sections. The opening section is not marked slower, but it is clearly written slower. I am, I suppose, a minority of one for believing that the opening section should be played actually slower - something that the Oberon quartet in this performance hints at by taking large rubatos, though the basic tempo does not change.

It is interesting that both the Haydn opus 76 and the Beethoven opus 18 quartets were written at the same time, and were both dedicated to the prince Joseph Franz Maximilian Lobkowicz. It was the custom in those days to give the manuscript to the dedicatee, who held it for a year or so to share with his friends before publishing it. It is therefore likely that Beethoven and/or Haydn saw the others' quartets in manuscript before publication, and were perhaps inspired one by the other. Is it possible that the last movement of the Malinconia was inspired by Haydn's Sunrise?


  1. Haydn did most things first! However, I did once read about how one of Mozart's chamber works suddenly seems to dive down into some random chord, which has been forgotten or glossed over by the fact of his more popular works, yet if Beethoven had done the same thing, the critics would have been all over it. Can't remember where I read that, sorry. I'm also always reminded of the 4th mvnt of Mozart's Symphony No.40 and the 11 tone chromatic modulating passage before the development section.

  2. Modest Mussorgsky was a 19th century Russian composer. His most famous works include “Night on Bald Mountain,” “Boris Godunov” and “Pictures at an Exhibition.”
    Along with Piotr Ilyitch Tchaikovsky, the greatest Russian composer of the Nineteenth Century, Modest Petrovich Mussorgsky (March 9, 1839 – March 16, 1881) was born into a wealthy rural, landowning family. He began by picking out on the piano the tunes he heard from the serfs on his family’s estate. At the age of six, he began to study piano with his mother. I liked your blog, Take the time to visit the me and say that the change in design and meniu?